Thursday, 10 November 2022

"The Banshees of Inisherin" - Review

During the Irish civil war of 1923, the people of Inisherin live a quiet and quaint existence. This is shattered for local farmer Padraic (Colin Farrell) when his best (and perhaps only) friend, grouchy folk musician Colm (Brendan Gleeson) abruptly ends their friendship. Padraic tries to figure out why, and falls deeper and deeper into despair, whilst the community itself tries to meddle and recover too.

This is classic McDonagh, but playwright McDonagh more than film McDonagh. A "feel bad comedy" which, and I cannot understate this, is VERY funny (it has the best joke about a bread van I have ever heard in my life, and it was a welcome respite for my tense cinema) but undercut and intrinsically woven with a pitch black story about divides, the meaning of friendship, and our own dreadful existential realisations. Fun stuff.
Classic McDonagh! There are excellent little touches (the sound of gunfire and explosions on the mainland during a confrontation, other characters reading the paper regarding the civil war, and trying to figure out who will win and why they are fighting) and some great supporting turns (Kerry Condon is excellent) but it remains largely a 2-man show with a fantastic Farrell and glorious Gleeson. They flip dynamics, play off of each other, get one up on each other, and own the stage (for this, despite its cinematic flair and trappings, is still very much a stage play) in this petty, narrow minded game. In the end nothing matters, none of this does, and it's gruelling as a result.
The ending has no real closure, it ends on a bleak note, and I would expect nothing less from McDonagh. We as people don't make sense, we're irrational, we hold grudges, we're petty, we're pretentious, we're casually cruel.
It's excellent cinema.
But maybe watch a nice light hearted affair afterwards, to rinse the taste.

No comments:

Post a Comment